posted
Hi Guys, Gee, I was clueless that Amtrak began to run the Cardinal from NYC to Chi 3 times per week. I was gong to take Three Rivers. What can you tell me about the Cardinal? How does it compare to Three Rivers? Thanks for any info. Scott
cassrr Member # 1834
posted
Pretty typical East coast single level train...dorm/lounge which currently serves as baggage car, single sleeper, full diner, snack-lounge, three coaches. Travels thru WV's New River Gorge (best viewed in winter on eastbound)and along the Ohio River to Cincinnati. Lately been pretty full, too. Usually 1-2 hours late both directions. Crew changes that occurred in October when the run was extended to NYP definitely saw an improved service crew. Crews like the Cardinal; it's a cash cow with all the overtime!
Geoff Mayo Member # 153
posted
My favorite east coast - Chicago train! Well worth experiencing, but from what I hear, the Three Rivers is equally good.
When I rode it (when it still had Superliners), you could look out the back as there seems to be rarely anything attached (like boxcars etc).
Geoff M.
RDG484 Member # 2907
posted
I would pick the Cardinal because it runs through the New River Gorge, although I don't know if it is in daylight or darkness.
jefffromark Member # 827
posted
I love the fact that the Cardinal has been extended back into NYC. Makes it a good 26 hour ride compared to 20 hours on the Three Rivers or Lake Shore. Plus the passengers and crew are a bit more laid back. Also if your a sleeping car passenger you can look forward to an additional meal. Im not sure about todays Cardinal but back in the early 90's they served breakfast out of NYC, lunch was available upon arriving Washington, dinner around Clifton Forge and breafast again before we got to Indianapolis. I remember being told you needed to be in the dining car upon arriving Indy because all the new people boarding Indy would just cram into the diner - they were right it was unreal.
So if I was in your shoes I would make one trip on the Three Rivers and one on the Cardinal. Yes eastbound is better if your into river scenery but I never liked the late evening arrival times into the northeast.
posted