RailForum.com
TrainWeb.com

RAILforum Post A Reply
my profile | directory login | register | search | faq | forum home

» RAILforum » Passenger Trains » Amtrak » Five Amtrivia Questions » Post A Reply

Post A Reply
Login Name:
Password:
Message Icon: Icon 1     Icon 2     Icon 3     Icon 4     Icon 5     Icon 6     Icon 7    
Icon 8     Icon 9     Icon 10     Icon 11     Icon 12     Icon 13     Icon 14    
Message:

HTML is not enabled.
UBB Code™ is enabled.

 

Instant Graemlins Instant UBB Code™
Smile   Frown   Embarrassed   Big Grin   Wink   Razz  
Cool   Roll Eyes   Mad   Eek!   Confused    
Insert URL Hyperlink - UBB Code™   Insert Email Address - UBB Code™
Bold - UBB Code™   Italics - UBB Code™
Quote - UBB Code™   Code Tag - UBB Code™
List Start - UBB Code™   List Item - UBB Code™
List End - UBB Code™   Image - UBB Code™

What is UBB Code™?
Options


Disable Graemlins in this post.


 


T O P I C     R E V I E W
dnsommer
Member # 2825
 - posted
Five Amtrivia Questions

1. Name an Amtrak train that operated in "dark territory."

2. Over which eye did James J. Hill wear a patch, and why?

3. Name the town where the southbound Coast Starlight begins its ascent of the Oregon Cascades.

4. Which cost more to build: Cincinnati Union Terminal or Los Angeles Union Station? (BONUS: Which of the two was designed to handle 33 trains a day.)

5. Name two cities that have more than one Amtrak station as of 11/02/2003, and name the stations.

[This message has been edited by dnsommer (edited 11-02-2003).]
 

Mr. Toy
Member # 311
 - posted
#3 Oakridge.

The rest, I dunno.
 

RRRICH
Member # 1418
 - posted
#5 - Stockton, CA - San Joaquin St. Station and ACE station

Boston, MA - South Station and Back Bay Station
 

JonA
Member # 2690
 - posted
Doesn't the downeaster leave from North Station in BOS. That would make 3.
 
dnsommer
Member # 2825
 - posted
#3 is correct, Mr. Toy. The answer is Oakridge.

Your answer to #5 also is correct, RRRich. There is one more Amtrak station in Boston, however. And another city with two stations remains unmentioned.

Dave
 

dnsommer
Member # 2825
 - posted
You are correct, JonA. Boston has 3 stations.

Dave
 

MPALMER
Member # 125
 - posted
DNSommer,
Does Los Angeles count? The Surfliner serves LAUS, Van Nuys and Chatsworth. The latter two are both San Fernando Valley regions of Los Angeles.
MP
 
CG96
Member # 1408
 - posted
A guess as to #1: The KY cardinal, between Indianapolis & Louisville. I think certain sections of the track between those two cities was un-signalled territory.
 
MPALMER
Member # 125
 - posted
quote:
Originally posted by CG96:
A guess as to #1: The KY cardinal, between Indianapolis & Louisville. I think certain sections of the track between those two cities was un-signalled territory.

I was going to guess the pre-Cardinal James Whitcomb Riley, which was rerouted through Indiana several times and possibly one or more of those routes was dark.
 

MPALMER
Member # 125
 - posted
quote:
Originally posted by dnsommer:
Five Amtrivia Questions

2. Over which eye did James J. Hill wear a patch, and why?


[This message has been edited by dnsommer (edited 11-02-2003).]


I don't remember which eye, but I believe he lost it in a childhood bows-and-arrows contest.
MP
 

UncleBuck44
Member # 2049
 - posted
#1: California Zephyr, maybe. Dark Territory is in Under Siege 2. I know the Train went from Denver to LA and the Zephyr goes to Denver, but Denver isnt part of D.T. It might be no trains, but im going with the Zephyr.

#4: Cincinnati, I think its a trick question sort of. Most might think LA but its actually Cincy.

#5: St. Louis(St.Louis Downtown and Kirkwood, a suburb of STL)
 

dnsommer
Member # 2825
 - posted
Some of your answers were unanticipated. I don't think Van Nuys and Chatsworth count in the sense that my question intended, but they may very well be correct in terms of being within LA city limits. So... Well... I'm only going to say there's an as yet unmentioned city with two stations and the city's name is part of the name of both stations, such as Boston - North Station and Boston - South Station.

The 'dark territory' trains mentioned so far are not the one I had in mind, but you guys could be right nevertheless.

I'll post the answers I have tomorrow evening. I guess I better brace for possible attack!

Dave
 

dnsommer
Member # 2825
 - posted
You answered Question #4 correctly Uncle Buck. CUT cost $41 million and LAUPT cost $11 million.

The bonus question remains unanswered.

Dave

[This message has been edited by dnsommer (edited 11-04-2003).]
 

dnsommer
Member # 2825
 - posted
Question #1 is not a trick. There was a regularly scheduled train that operated in dark territory. It also is the only train that operated on a shortline.
 
Kairho
Member # 1567
 - posted
Well Philadelphia has 30th Street and North Philadelphia stations, but I am not sure if Amtrak still stops at the latter...
 
stlboomer
Member # 2028
 - posted
5. Dearborn, MI and Greenfield Village, MI - both in Dearborn.
 
chrisg
Member # 2488
 - posted
posted 11-02-2003 07:35 PM               
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Five Amtrivia Questions

1. Name an Amtrak train that operated in "dark territory." The Janesville Service did as did the Kentucky Cardinal.

2. Over which eye did James J. Hill wear a patch, and why? Left, after a childhood accident.

3. Name the town where the southbound Coast Starlight begins its ascent of the Oregon Cascades. Oakridge

4. Which cost more to build: Cincinnati Union Terminal or Los Angeles Union Station? (BONUS: Which of the two was designed to handle 33 trains a day.)
Los Angeles Union Passenger Station.

5. Name two cities that have more than one Amtrak station as of 11/02/2003, and name the stations.

Boston and Stckton,Ca
 

RRCHINA
Member # 1514
 - posted

#2: Mr. Hill had his right eye injured at age nine when his homemade bow broke and the arrow released back into the eye. His eye was never removed but he had no vision in it for the remainder of his life.
 
UncleBuck44
Member # 2049
 - posted
Bonus#4: Cincinnati

Was my Answer to Number 5 correct, with St. Louis?

[This message has been edited by UncleBuck44 (edited 11-04-2003).]
 

dnsommer
Member # 2825
 - posted
Answers to Five Amtrivia Questions

1. Name an Amtrak train that operated in "dark territory."

The Vermonter operated on RailTex's New England Central shortline between St. Albans, VT and Palmer, MA for a period of time, and this was dark territory, according 'The Ultimate Encyclopedia of Steam & Rail' by Colin Garratt and Max Wade Mathews.

This route also made The Vermonter the only Amtrak train that did not operate on a Class 1 railroad. I believe the train now runs once again on Guilford trackage north of Springfield, MA.

I also believe the Vermonter went south of Palmer to New London for a period of time, too.

The guys who wrote this book may be partially incorrect. It did and still does run St. Albans-White River Jct.-Brattleboro on former Central Vermont tracks. But I suspect what they wrote about the train operating Brattleboro-Palmer-Springfield-New Haven and then south is wrong. I think it operated Brattleboro-Palmer-New London and then south.

2. Over which eye did James J. Hill wear a patch, and why?

Right eye/bow and arrow mishap. RRChina got it


3. Name the town where the southbound Coast Starlight begins its ascent of the Oregon Cascades.

Oakridge. Mr. Toy got it first.


4. Which cost more to build: Cincinnati Union Terminal or Los Angeles Union Station? (BONUS: Which of the two was designed to handle 33 trains a day.)

Cincinnati Union Terminal, opened in 1933. It cost a record $41 million depression era dollars to build. Uncle Buck got this one, but it is $11 million dollar LAUPT that was designed to handle just 33 trains a day. CUT was designed to handle 216. Now it handles just one, while LAUPT handles many, many more than 33. An intersting turn of events. (info from 'Great American Train Stations', Hans and April Halberstadt)

5. Name two cities that have more than one Amtrak station as of 11/02/2003, and name the stations.

Boston - North Station, South Station, Back Bay Station

Richmond, VA - Staples Mill Road Station, Main Street Station

[This message has been edited by dnsommer (edited 11-04-2003).]

[This message has been edited by dnsommer (edited 11-05-2003).]
 

dnsommer
Member # 2825
 - posted
If the Dearborn Stations are both within Dearborn's city limits, it is a valid answer, The same would apply to St Louis and Kirkwood. However, I am fairly certain Kirkwood is its own separate municipality.

What I was looking for was a city with two stations with the same city name, as provided in the answers.

I am unfamiliar with 'Stockton ACE' station. What is ACE?

Stockton is yet another correct answer.

[This message has been edited by dnsommer (edited 11-04-2003).]

[This message has been edited by dnsommer (edited 11-04-2003).]
 

dnsommer
Member # 2825
 - posted
When did Pomona, CA move and lose/combine one of its two former Amtrak Stations? They were at:

-156 W. Commercial Street (Sunset Ltd)
-2701 N. Garey Avenue (SW Chief)

Current timetable lists one Pomona station at 100 W. Commercial Street.

Too bad. I rather liked the N. Garey Avenue ATSF depot.

Dave

[This message has been edited by dnsommer (edited 11-04-2003).]

[This message has been edited by dnsommer (edited 11-04-2003).]
 

JFB
Member # 2520
 - posted
I'm afraid Richmond, Va doesn't work. Two reasons: Staples Mill Road is not within Richmond City limits, and, most importantly, Amtrak doesn't use Broad Street Station.

You may be confusing Broad Street Station with Main Street Station. Both still exist, but neither is active.

Broad Street was the city's "union station," used most famously by Florida trains. It was abandoned early in the Amtrak era, and converted into a science museum in (I think) the 1980s.

Main Street is an older, partially-abandoned, ex-RF&P station. Amtrak trains to Newport News roll by it, but haven't stopped there for decades (if ever). Work is presently underway to restore service to the station as part of a larger economic revival of downtown Richmond, but no concrete date has been set for completion.

The Vermonter still travels from Palmer to St. Albans on the New Englad Central (ex-CV), and is not likely to return to Guilford's Connecticut River line anytime soon. The problems started in 1987, when Guilford downgraded its Springfield-Brattleboro segment, forcing Amtrak to re-route the Montrealer--the Vermonter's predecessor--to the Central Vermont via New London. Later, Amtrak amended the re-route to join the CV at Palmer, decreasing mileage and returning Vermont/Montreal service to Springfield. The Vermonter travels this same route to St. Albans today.

Not sure how much of that remains dark teritory.

[This message has been edited by JFB (edited 11-04-2003).]
 

UncleBuck44
Member # 2049
 - posted
I am also Fairly certain that Kirkwood is in St. Louis County
 
dnsommer
Member # 2825
 - posted
Thanks JFB for the clarification! Any chance of a restoration of service betwen St. Albans and Montreal?

Correction to Question #5 ANSWER...
I meant to write Richmond/Staples Mill Road and Richmond/Main Street Station - not Broad Street Station.

Main Street Station was scheduled to reopen on 10/30/2003. Anyone know if it actually has reopened? Trains have passed through the station but not stopped since 1975 when a severe flood of The James River made the facility unsafe.

Richmond plans to make Main Street Station a regional intermodal transit center now that the building and surrounding district it's in are protected by new floodwalls erected in 1999. So far, these floodwalls remain untested.

The rails leading to Main Street Station are on very high, sturdy trestles. It's also just steps away from the famous triple crossing.

David

[This message has been edited by dnsommer (edited 11-04-2003).]

[This message has been edited by dnsommer (edited 11-04-2003).]

[This message has been edited by dnsommer (edited 11-05-2003).]
 

dnsommer
Member # 2825
 - posted
I double-checked the location of Staples Mill Road. It is in zip code 23228, which is handled by the City of Richmond post office. It also appears to be within city limits on a Mapquest map, but just barely.

Richmond's Main Street station was re-opened in October, 2003 after a major renovation. However, for the time being, only Amtrak's Newport News trains will be using it.

Dave

 

zephyr
Member # 1651
 - posted
I may have to call a technical foul on Question 2.

The question was: "Over which eye did James J. Hill wear a patch, and why."

RRCHINA got the details of JJ's blindness in his right eye correct, and I suggest he should be allowed to keep that great prize he won. Heck, he probably has already squandered his winnings and it would be difficult if not impossible to get him to return it.

But the question was over which eye he wore a patch, and why. My answer is neither eye, except for an occassional halloween when he dressed up as a pirate, or maybe when he was cruising pickup bars and used the patch thing to look "mysterious." Or maybe he used a patch over his left eye when he discovered the morning afer that his catch at those aforementioned saloons was coyote ugly.

You see, I never have come across a photo of JJ wearing a patch over his eye. His statue in front of the Havre, MT, station: no patch that I recall. His images that can be found in and around the Astoria Column: again, no patch.

So I posed the patch question to Eileen R. McCormack, Assoc. Curator, James J. Hill Library in St. Paul, MN. Her response: "As far as I know he never wore a patch. Although the optic nerve was destroyed, he did have muscular control over the eye so the loss of vision was not apparent to others."

So, unless someone can document evidence to the contrary, I stand by my answer to Question #2. Again, my answer is seldom if ever, and if he did, it had something to do with halloween or womanizing.


[This message has been edited by zephyr (edited 11-05-2003).]
 

dnsommer
Member # 2825
 - posted
According to Lucius Beebe, "Hill was small in stature, one-eyed, and bearded, which gave him a look entirely piratical."

You're right! No mention of a patch! Perhaps the word 'pirate' subliminally suggests he wore a patch, and thus my error was born.

1. Attach keyboard to foot.
2. Put foot in mouth.

Dave
 

MPALMER
Member # 125
 - posted
quote:
Originally posted by dnsommer:
I am unfamiliar with 'Stockton ACE' station. What is ACE?

Stockton is yet another correct answer.

[/B]


ACE = Altamont Commuter Express. It is a rush-hour only weekday service that runs from Stockton to San Jose, started in the late 90s. It uses a platform adjacent to the SP station in Stockton. The Amtrak San Joaquins that run to Sacramento also use this station platform; the other San Joaquins use the Santa Fe station.

MP
 

MPALMER
Member # 125
 - posted
quote:
Originally posted by dnsommer:
[B]When did Pomona, CA move and lose/combine one of its two former Amtrak Stations? They were at:

-156 W. Commercial Street (Sunset Ltd)
-2701 N. Garey Avenue (SW Chief)

Current timetable lists one Pomona station at 100 W. Commercial Street.

Dave


Amtrak rerouted the now-gone Desert Wind in April '86 to the Santa Fe route via Fullerton. The Southwest Chief was then rerouted via Fullerton early in '94, and the Pomona and Pasadena stations closed.

In Pomona Metrolink has a station platform on the adjacent ex-SP/PE not far from the old Santa Fe station. The SF station area *I think* is used for maintenance supplies (signals etc)
MP
 

amtraxmaniac
Member # 2251
 - posted
LAUPT I believe was designed to handle MORE than 33 trains per day, so I think it's Cincy.

FYI: There will soon be two in OAK. The existing one at Jack London and a new one soon at the Colliseum adjacent to BART.


Patrick.
 

Amtrak207
Member # 1307
 - posted
1. Maybe sections of the JWR? I cheated on that one. No credit.
2. The middle one. I don't know. No credit.
3. I haven't a clue. One of these days, I'll get there. You could ask something about Helper, Utah, though...
4. Cincinatti. Nice to see two trains a day still stop there at 4:30 in the morning.
5. Boston South and Boston Back Bay, I knew that part (partial credit) and now for the fun...

Wrong, wrong, wrong. I will be right because (unfortunately) it's where I am.

And the winning answers are...
Buffalo-Depew station, and
Buffalo-Exchange Street station.

Where are my 2500 Guest Rewards points for getting that right??? I'm serious!

Exchange Street had a number of overpasses built literally right on top of it. Think of Milwaukee but way, way worse. Parking is limited to in between on-ramp columns. Absolutely beautiful. The station itself is fairly pleasing on the outside except for the remains of the neon-lit sign- get a new drumhead or strike it already!
Depew is where I've done the majority of my foaming over the last couple years while at school. It's got open air above it. Of course, we had to put a landfill half a mile away, and on nights like last night, the smell is very unpleasant. The building has been expanded at least twice, and it still can't hold enough people. Parking is occasionally a dilemma, but that's just because I should be able to ride my bike there. Visibility at the station is excellent. The staff are friendly, and the inside of the station is clean and well-kept.
 

dnsommer
Member # 2825
 - posted
Very perceptive, 207. How could anyone overlook Buffalo? You are correct.

So we have Buffalo Exchange and Depew. We have Boston South, North, and Back Bay. We have Stockton Amtrak and ACE. We have Richmond Main Street and Staples Mill Rd (with some debate).

Cities with two stations geographically but not in name include Dearborn/Greenfield Village, MI (unconfirmed; but a basic search shows this is correct) and St. Louis/Kirkwood, MO (Kirkwood being within The City of St. Louis proper - not county - remains unconfirmed).

And when a small ship hit the Empire Service Manhattan Swing Bridge a year or so ago NYC had both Penn Station and Grand Central as Amtrak stations once more, if only for a day, but just for a day. This fact never really counted, though.

And incidentally, until not so long ago, Philadelphia had three Amtrak Stations: 30th Street Station, Suburban Station (Penn Center), and 52nd Street Station. What happened? And is North Philadelphia part of Philadelphia proper, or is it a separate municipality? If North Philadelphia is part of Philadelphia, The Cream Cheese City would have been an all-time record holder, with a total number of four Amtrak Stations within its city limits.

Chicago. How many stations did Amtrak ever operate from simultaneously in Chicago? What were they? In Amtrak's early days Central Station was used. What became of the place? And were there other stations? What trains used which stations? When were all Chicago Amtrak operations consolidated at Union Station?

And then there is Montreal. Montreal was once served by Amtrak trains at Montreal-Central CN (Montrealer/Washingtonian), and Montreal- Windsor CP(Adirondack). As most of you know, only The Adirondack serves Montreal now, and it uses Central Station/VIA. Was a special track needed to bring the Adirondack into Central? Didn't both The Adirondondack and The Montrealer cross the US/Canadian Border at the same place and use the same tracks to Montreal itself? Did they cross the St. Lawrence on different bridges? What became of Windsr Station? Isn't Windsor Station some sort of mall or atrium arcade now? Windsor Station was a great but sadly empty station when I was visited it in the early '80s.

Come to think of it, The Montrealer used to serve both Montreal-Central and Montreal-West, if I'm not mistaken.

But it's all mere history now. Maybe if we forget about the past, it will repeat itself.

In some respects, that would be okay with me.

Dave

[This message has been edited by dnsommer (edited 11-08-2003).]

[This message has been edited by dnsommer (edited 11-08-2003).]
 

stlboomer
Member # 2028
 - posted
Kirkwood, MO and St. Louis, MO are separate municipalities located in separate counties. No question about it. Occasional confusion out there perhaps result of excessive positive ions?

DER and GFV are both within the Dearborn, MI city limits. The address shown in the national timetable for GFV is the Henry Ford Museum. Interestingly, according to the USPS website the zipcode shown for GFV (48216) is incorrect. That's a Detroit zipcode. Both the USPS and the Museum's website show the Museum's address within zipcode 48124 (Dearborn).

[This message has been edited by stlboomer (edited 11-08-2003).]
 

Kairho
Member # 1567
 - posted
>And incidentally, until not so long ago, Philadelphia had three Amtrak Stations: 30th Street Station, Suburban Station (Penn Center), and 52nd Street Station. What happened? And is North Philadelphia part of Philadelphia proper, or is it a separate municipality?

North Philadelphia ia only an area of the City of Philadelphia, not a separate entity. So that's a definite 2.

I am a couple of years out of date on the others, though. If I recall, Suburban Station is used only for the SEPTA commuter trains, and not the long distance (Amtrak) trains going west towards Harrisburg. I believe the latter all terminate at 30th Street (or continued onorth to NYC or south towards DC)..

And I believe 52nd street is just a subway stop; I don't recall any "real" train station there ... nor at 69th Street. If there ever was, it was very-pre-1960s.
 

irishchieftain
Member # 1473
 - posted
Indeed, where is this supposed 52nd Street Philadelphia Amtrak station...?
 
UncleBuck44
Member # 2049
 - posted
quote:
Originally posted by stlboomer:
Kirkwood, MO and St. Louis, MO are separate municipalities located in separate counties.

[This message has been edited by stlboomer (edited 11-08-2003).]



Kirkwood is located in St. Louis County

 

Kairho
Member # 1567
 - posted
Thinking more about this 52nd Street station, the subway stop I'm thinking of is 52nd and Market Street, on the Market-Frankford line. That's no where near the Amtrak lines, which are more north, towards Overbrook.
 
dnsommer
Member # 2825
 - posted
For many years, Amtrak "Silverliner" service between Philadelphia and Harrisburg originated at Suburban Station (Penn Center) The trains then called at 30th Street-Penn Station, one mile away. Amtrak's Philadelphia - 52nd Street Station was between 30th Street and Overbrook, PA.

The station was unmanned. It is shown in the May, 1974 timetable through at least the October, 1979 timetable, but no address for it was provided. 52nd Street Station was served by one train, Silverliner #601, and it stopped at the station at the very early hour of 5:53 a.m. on weekdays. Anybody ever ride it?

New York City also had some "close in" stops on the mainlines long ago. The NYC had stations at 59th Street and 86th Street along Park Avenue.

Similarly. the New Haven RR had stops along its Hell Gate Route in The Bronx. Amtrak flies right through The Bronx nowadays. There is no commuter service on the line. Some public transit supporters in the New York City area have suggested bringing commuter service back to the Hell Gate Line. Many New Haven Line commuters would find Penn Station more convenient to their offices than Grand Central, but Metro North says that while such service could be provided, Penn Station itself has no capacity for any more trains than those the station already handles from Amtrak, NJT, and the LIRR.

The LIRR's former main line segment from Jamaica to Long Island City opposite midtown Manhattan lost its passenger service not too long ago. In its final decade this poorly patronized line decayed into a bumpy, decrepit branch line through the heart of Queens. The LIRR still provides some service to Atlantic Avenue and Hunterspoint Avenue within Queens and Brooklyn. There is talk now of extending the Atlantic Avenue branch into lower Manhattan.

All of these former trunk lines once had smaller stations within the city limits besides their principal terminals, much like 52nd Street in Philadelphia.

Dave

[This message has been edited by dnsommer (edited 11-09-2003).]

[This message has been edited by dnsommer (edited 11-09-2003).]
 

stlboomer
Member # 2028
 - posted
Yes, UB44, Kirkwood is in St. Louis County, but St. Louis city isn't. St. Louis city isn't in any county. Check it out if you don't believe me. Besides, the original question asked for cities with more than one Amtrak station - not counties.
 



Contact Us | Home Page

Powered by Infopop Corporation
UBB.classic™ 6.7.2




Copyright © 2007-2016 TrainWeb, Inc. Top of Page|TrainWeb|About Us|Advertise With Us|Contact Us