posted
About a week ago I was watching the Weather Channel and happen to see a new Amtrak National commercial promoting Long Distance train travel.
I set my recorder that night, and as lucky enough to pick up the same commercial airing later.
I uploaded it onto my computer, and here is a link to it on YouTube. Enjoy! Link
City of Miami Member # 2922
posted
Cewell.
tommers207 Member # 3930
posted
I think it's great that they do this but what they need to show is the fantastic scenery you see from a train and not some annimated train. Amtrak needs to sell the experience and promote the destinations and not just give out general information.
wayne72145 Member # 4503
posted
Thanks for the link--Ive already sent it to a few folks. Random acts of travel---PERFECT
Henry Kisor Member # 4776
posted
At first I liked the "random acts" play on "random acts of kindness," but then "random" started to bring other things to mind, like random delays, random quality in the diner, etc. It was a good idea at first but I think Tommers is right -- we need scenery, not animation. Donner Pass, Gore Canyon, the Cascades -- those will sell Amtrak a lot better, in my opinion.
Doc Brown Member # 4724
posted
Thanks for posting that! As a casual rail-fan and one who has not yet taken my first long distance trip on Amtrak, I have to say I can't see how this would motivate anyone to take a rail trip. Some of our friends already think we're nuts for spending four days round trip on a train. I thought the couple toasting in the diner was a nice touch, but it would be a lot more effective if they were real people. I agree, show the scenery too! It might not hurt to have a comercial dedicated to showing the advatages of train travel vs. flying too.
Henry Kisor Member # 4776
posted
If I were designing an Amtrak ad, I would open with a broad shot of Terminal 3 at O'Hare during a fierce snowstorm with all the flights on the departure board reading "CANCELLED"and people packed into the waiting areas sleeping every which way on baggage ... then dissolve to happy couples toasting each other in the diner to the rumble of the train as the storm roars unheard outside. Unfair....but effective.
TwinStarRocket Member # 2142
posted
If such advertising increases ridership, especially in the summer when the LD system runs near capacity, how long will it take to get new superliners funded, designed and built? A surge in ticket sales automatically results in this new equipment showing up wherever needed, right?
The ad is nice, but I would rather see the improvement of current service be a priority. I hate to be pessimistic, but I fear that more first timers will just become "never agains".
CoastStarlight99 Member # 2734
posted
quote:Originally posted by Henry Kisor: If I were designing an Amtrak ad, I would open with a broad shot of Terminal 3 at O'Hare during a fierce snowstorm with all the flights on the departure board reading "CANCELLED"and people packed into the waiting areas sleeping every which way on baggage ... then dissolve to happy couples toasting each other in the diner to the rumble of the train as the storm roars unheard outside. Unfair....but effective.
That sounds like an excellent idea. I think Santa Fe once had a slogan "Next Time, Take the TRAIN". Amtrak could really play with that using billboards near airports, etc.
-Anton
TBlack Member # 181
posted
I hope somebody at AMTRAK monitors this board. In less than a day there are some wonderful ideas for an ad campaign, at no cost to AMTRAK!
We can complain about the animation, but it's cheaper than doing the real thing.
Mr. Toy Member # 311
posted
I kinda liked the animation. Clean and simple. I wouldn't consider it the last word on advertising campaigns, but it looked nice.
I agree that Mr. Kisor's "canceled flights" idea has a lot of merit, but such a campaign is necessarily seasonal. It won't work now that we're going into Spring. But in November....
CHI_Amtrak_Fan Member # 4004
posted
I agree with Mr. Toy. I like the simple and clean animation with the driving music behind the voiceover. I would prefer the same voice announces the destinations at the end of the commercial.
Doc Brown Member # 4724
posted
quote:Originally posted by Mr. Toy: I kinda liked the animation. Clean and simple. I wouldn't consider it the last word on advertising campaigns, but it looked nice.
I agree that Mr. Kisor's "canceled flights" idea has a lot of merit, but such a campaign is necessarily seasonal. It won't work now that we're going into Spring. But in November....
Oh I don't know. During the warm weather they could change the ads to scenes of long lines at the security gates with frustrated shoeless travelers. Then flash to relaxed passengers boarding a train. Flash back to a shot on a plane of cramped 3 across seats and inattentive flight attendants. Back to a scene of comfortable, relaxed people on the wide 2 across seats of a train, with a helpful and polite car attendant. Add to that a scene of the obersavation deck, the scenery, someone with a drink in their hands, well, you get the idea.
This country has become so focused on "hurry, hurry, hurry", that we've fogotten what it's like to take our time. Most people have no idea what train travel could be like. Gee, that's another idea, a "slow down and relax" ad campaign. Hey this is fun!
TwinStarRocket Member # 2142
posted
Although these ads showing the downside of other travel modes might please us rail advocates, there is an historical precedent that might suggest they could offend the political powers that be.
During the 70's there was a period of long gas station lines, Sunday closings, and stations running out of gas. Long distance auto travel became much less convenient, even risky.
Amtrak ran a large, very clever newspaper ad nationally showing a cute rural train station with the heading "Our stations will be open this summer".
These ads quickly disappeared. According to railfan rumors I read, certain officials in the Carter administration were convinced the ads would fuel a panic about gas availability; and even threatened tax audits of newspapers that did not pull them quickly enough.
Now we don't want to suggest that enduring Homeland Security precautions are anything less than an act of patriotism, do we? Everyone should know that if you don't support the oil, auto and airline industry, you are aiding the enemy.
HopefulRailUser Member # 4513
posted
I heard an Amtrak ad on the radio today. I missed the beginning but the part I heard noted the ability to move about and use the diner and observation cars and quoted fares from LA to Seattle and the Grand Canyon. Ended with "Book your trip now at Amtrak.com". Pretty nice.
Room Service Member # 2405
posted
Anton. You're sure stirring things up with your posts lately.
Thanks!
CoastStarlight99 Member # 2734
posted
quote:Originally posted by Room Service: Anton. You're sure stirring things up with your posts lately.
Thanks!
I try...
wayne72145 Member # 4503
posted
I wish I were being taped last July as I sat in a cramped commuter airling on the tarmac in Washington DC for 3 1/2 hours waiting for take off. I said to myself many times that day that this was the last time, the next time I get delayed it will be on Amtrak, where it's roomy and comfortable AND a lot more fun. I havent been back on a plane since that trip and I've been a vocal advertisement for Amtrak since.
Henry Kisor Member # 4776
posted
One of the old passenger railroads (D&RGW?) had a tongue-in-cheek slogan, "Go Through the Mountains, Not Into Them." I liked that one.
TwinStarRocket Member # 2142
posted
In today's Minneapolis Star Tribune there is a 7x10 ad with silhouettes of a couple in the diner with wine on the table and moonlight and mountains outside the window. The caption is "The cure for 'We never talk anymore.'"
There is a listing of six sample destination fares from MSP, and the silhouette of a superliner train on the bottom.
Well done.
notelvis Member # 3071
posted
quote:Originally posted by Room Service: Anton. You're sure stirring things up with your posts lately.
Thanks!
Yeah.
What he said.
Someone (or several someones) is teaching you well!
Regarding 1970's advertising, does anyone remember the National Timetable about 1978 or so that had the Amfleet train squirting out of a bottle of medicine? It said something like "Take Amtrak to relieve gas pains."
posted ![[Razz]](tongue.gif)